To know exactly why old forester decided to jump on the rye whiskey craze youll have to ask the folks at brownforman. Often, old overholt is the only rye whiskey one can easily find. For context, i put it sidebysidebyside with the old overholt 80 proof rye and the jim beam rye at 90 proof. There used to be a lot of older rittenhouse ryes on the market ive seen a 21 year, but they all got snapped up when old american whiskey. As the story goes during revolutionary times the british blocked shipments of molasses for rum making. Old overholt bonded is not a new release i mean it is, but it isnt. Jim beam takes its rye whiskey game to 100 proof with the affordable old overholt bonded. Its renowned for its outstanding mixability in classic cocktails.
After extensive testing, i agree old overholt rye is the. The true story of old overholt rye whisky advocate. Ok, ok, my testing wasnt terribly scientific its not like ive tried every bargain liquor out there shudder but i have bought quite a few bottles of this rye by now, and its become a. The 12 best rye whiskeys you can buy in 2018 gear patrol. Longstanding brands such as old overholt from pennsylvania and rittenhouse. While it was loved for its very affordable price tag, it was also nothing special, not even the benchmark among kentucky rye whiskeys. Sazerac the original sazerac recipe and the sazerac bar. Review of rittenhouse rye 100 proof the scotch noob. Bourbon and whiskey mash bills modernthirst has compiled one of the most comprehensive compilations of bourbon and whiskey mash bill recipes on the net. The recipe is based on a historic one for the old normandy rye brand, and was crafted by brownforman master distiller chris morris and master taster jackie zykan. I appreciate that the folks at bulleit wanted their brand of rye to stand out from the others.
This might be why beam released a bottled in bond version of old overholt rye thats aged an additional year. Buffalo trace bourbon is our house bourbon at eureka. Both rittenhouse and pikesville use the same mashbill from heaven hill. David rittenhouse april 8, 1732 june 26, 1796 was an american astronomer, inventor, clockmaker, mathematician, surveyor, scientific instrument craftsman, and public official. Old overholt is the bottle of rye that needs to be on everybodys booze shelf. I also love rittenhouse in a boulevardier, the whiskeybased variation on the negroni. In the mouth, a fruity sweetness is tempered with soft oak and spice, making it a damn fine dram. This famous straight rye whiskey has a distinctive. Old overholt is a straight rye whiskey, bottled at 80 proof 40% abv. Well, after extensive testing, i would have to agree. The nose may be a tad weak, but the flavor, finish and balance completely save the day.
In 1859, his son built a new distillery to continue production of old farm as well as a new spirit named for the overholt family. All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. Heaven hill the bottledinbond act of 1897 was introduced to ensure that whiskey producers were making their whiskey at a certain quality level and standard suitable for the public, explains adam harris, american whiskey ambassador with beam suntory. Old overholt tastes to me more like bourbon than rye. This is priced right to be either a sipper or as a great fruitforward cocktail base.
Last week old overholt bonded hit our local stores. Sazerac is buffalo traces entrylevel rye with nas rumored to be around 6 years old and is increasingly hard to find. Old overholt rye has had a steady presence on the bottom shelf of your local liquor store for decades, its founders face glaring at you from the label of every bottlebut it wasnt always that way. The difference is that pikesville is 2 years older and 10 proof higher. According to the bottle, the company began in 1810 outside of pittsburgh. Explore thousands of wines, spirits and beers, and shop online for delivery or pickup in a store near you. Rittenhouse straight rye 100 proof whiskey master of malt. Rich in flavor and full of complex notes that run the gamut from. No as good as whistle pig, but rd the price of whistle pig. The plain brown bottle and its simple yellow label testify to this american ryes unassuming nature. Its the backbone for my favorite old fashioned, for example, and its also excellent in a manhattan.
While the overholt brand has been around since the 1800s, the brand has changed hands many times since then and at one point put out a boned rye. In all three cases, this was confirmed to me by the master distiller. Many people also know that most major distillery straight ryes are barely legal at 51 percent rye. It has the abv and spicy rye backbone required to build a full arsenal of cocktails, and also.
Modernthirst bourbon and whiskey mash bills table estimated percentage this table is updated as new information is available. Its complex, both spicy and a little sweet, and tastes very similar to old overholt and rittenhouse. All the while, old overholt soldiered on with just the one expression. Now made by jim beam, this whiskey tastes rather different than the preprohibition version. Several years ago, nora maynard, our cocktail columnist, made the case for old overholt rye, saying it was her best pick for bargain booze. Tasting elijah craigs new straight rye whiskey along side two other stalwart ryes from heaven hill. Old overholt is a straight rye whiskey, aged four years and bottled at 80 proof 40% alcohol.
Rittenhouse was a member of the american philosophical society and the first director of the united states mint. Named for the year the bottledinbond act was passed, old forester 1897 was released last year as part of the brands delicious whiskey row series. During this period when we are all challenged with supporting new methods of teaching, learning, and living, rittenhouse has solutions that can assist you and your patrons with these needs. It stayed had a bonded rye until sometime in the 60s from what i can find. You can also substitute simple syrup as they do at the sazerac bar and. Because of this, rittenhouse is priced perfectly for what it is.
The lowerproof version is your standard mixing rye, along the same lines as old overholt. Until recently, two versions of rittenhouse were available. Beam has finally addressed that oversight with the introduction of old overholt bonded. Im a fan of baby sazerac rye 6 year old which has some nice sweetness vs the dryness here. Rittenhouse bottledinbond straight rye bardstown, kentucky 100 proof sazerac straight rye. Old overholt, said to be americas oldest continually maintained brand of whiskey, was founded in west overton, pennsylvania, in 1810. In fact, a general rule would be to buy old overholt to save money, sazerac for an easy sipping rye and rittenhouse for ryebased cocktails. To know what it tastes like, youll only have to pay. Like so many modern kentucky rye whiskeys such as rittenhouse, michters, and pikesville, old overholt was initially a rye whiskey produced in the new england area during the period between the late 18th century and prohibition when pennsylvania and maryland rye dominated.
Nowadays, old overholt is owned by and distilled at jim beam in kentucky. This is true of heaven hill rittenhouse, jim beam jim beam, old overholt, knob creek, and buffalo trace sazerac. Id always thought of old overholt as a good starter rye different enough from bourbon to tell the difference, and at 80 proof, mild enough not to spook the novice drinker but as ive found myself with greater access to ryes such as sazerac 6year old and the rittenhouse 100 proof, ive let my bottle of old overcoat gather dust. Old overholt, with an unbroken chain of ownership and production that stretches back to 1810, was a national institution. Old overholt is a popular option, but thats a little dull in my book at 80proof. For some thats important, but for a few dollars more, rittenhouse rye bottled in bond is the better buy. In fact, old overholt was, at one time, one of the most respected and highly regarded whiskeys in the united states, said to have once been the preferred tipple of notables like ulysses s. Something cheap in the rye worldsay, old overholt or rittenhouse is still likely to cost you almost twice the price of the winner of our bottom shelf bourbon blind tasting, very old barton. The proof is high enough that you can be generous with the vermouth, and the drink wont get too sweet. Sazerac the original sazerac recipe and the sazerac bar in new orleans. Rittenhouse rye is a bartenders favorite at the price point. Do you know the difference between rye and canadian whisky. A look at the latest addition to the old overholt brand old overholt bonded. The best bourbons and ryes that are bottled in bond.
1209 1294 1289 399 304 4 646 903 545 439 949 928 557 446 752 1333 1363 515 822 466 919 929 213 1113 666 502 1268 1041 925 123 63 991 391 1397 1087 564 1303 1286 355 649 1029 578 647 1295